Open RAN: Challenges and Prospects on the Road to Maturity
By LitePointDecember 8, 2023
Hosted by RCR Wireless News, the Open RAN Global Forum is an annual event where leaders across the industry gather to discuss the field’s progress and greatest challenges. LitePoint’s Adam Smith joined a progress update panel, alongside representatives from Telecom Infra Project, NTIA, Intel, and Jio to share thoughts on the ecosystem’s maturity and evolution.
From the discussion, it’s clear that O-RAN is progressing quickly and in a positive direction. Still, O-RAN is facing a set of hurdles that must be overcome.
The O-RAN marketplace as a whole has evolved, as groups like the O-RAN Alliance develop and release specifications that define the interfaces and behaviors of different network components. As more players enter the marketspace, these specifications will guide vendors in building O-RAN-compliant products, which will ensure a higher level of uniformity and compatibility across the ecosystem.
As part of this effort, the industry has received a significant boon from governmental bodies. For example, the U.S. CHIPS and Science Act and similar initiatives in other countries are providing financial backing and regulatory support, further legitimizing standardization efforts for O-RAN.
Greater support for O-RAN is contributing to the modernization of networks. Whereas traditional networks often rely on proprietary hardware and software from a single vendor, O-RAN decouples hardware from software to enable interoperability among components from different vendors. As a result, O-RAN not only makes networks more agile, but simplifies their management, which streamlines operations and reduces the total cost of network ownership.
The truth is that O-RAN will only be useful if different vendors’ products work seamlessly together. Achieving true interoperability, however, is easier said than done.
For example, the industry is experiencing a notable misalignment of specifications between 3GPP, the group behind the 5G standard, and the O-RAN Alliance’s own set of standards. To avoid confusion and possible market fragmentation, these two major entities must align on a single set of standards to develop robust translation layers that can bridge these differences.
Some experts on the panel were skeptical of industry players’ willingness to coalesce around a single set of standards, questioning whether true “plug-and-play” interoperability is a realistic goal. Between vendor-specific differences in interpreting specifications, rapid and frequent changes in technology, and the obstacles of integrating O-RAN with deployed legacy systems, some panelists see interoperability as more aspirational than attainable.
Challenges with Diversity and Complexity
The O-RAN ecosystem is experiencing an influx of new players, particularly in the radio unit space.
On the one hand, this is a positive thing. It’s diversifying the ecosystem, offering network operators a broader range of choices for radio components. While incumbent telecom vendors traditionally served as the industry’s bedrock for R&D, companies that have not been in the wireless space historically are now entering the market.
On the other hand, diversity adds layers of complexity to managing the overall network. With more vendors, the task of ensuring seamless communication and operational efficiency becomes more intricate. As one panelist noted, today’s O-RAN ecosystem is almost five times more diverse than traditional RAN.
Is this diversity enriching the ecosystem or making it too cumbersome? The answer lies in a nuanced middle ground. While diversity fosters innovation and competition, thereby driving down costs and improving quality, it also complicates the task of network management and standardization. The industry will need to find a balanced approach that capitalizes on diversity while effectively managing the complexities that they introduce.
O-RAN is at a pivotal juncture in its development as the 5G ecosystem seeks to strike a balance between the promise of revolutionizing the telecommunications landscape and managing complexity.
The industry bears a collective responsibility to address these challenges. Vendors need to work together to align their interpretations of technical specifications and ensure that their products integrate seamlessly. This requires a commitment to ongoing collaboration and may involve the development of new governance structures or third-party bodies to oversee and facilitate this integration. Furthermore, investment in research and development will be necessary to solve the technical roadblocks that currently limit interoperability. Only by tackling these issues head-on can O-RAN move from a promising concept to a transformative reality in the telecommunications field.
To learn more about O-RAN and how it’s revolutionizing the wireless industry, check LitePoint’s 3 for 3 blog here.
Subscribe to the LitePoint Blog